Summary
Background
The first epidemic wave of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) in Scotland resulted in high case numbers and mortality in care homes. In Lothian, over one-third of care homes reported an outbreak, while there was limited testing of hospital patients discharged to care homes.
Aim
To investigate patients discharged from hospitals as a source of SARS-CoV-2 introduction into care homes during the first epidemic wave.
Methods
A clinical review was performed for all patients discharges from hospitals to care homes from 1st March 2020 to 31st May 2020. Episodes were ruled out based on coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) test history, clinical assessment at discharge, whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data and an infectious period of 14 days. Clinical samples were processed for WGS, and consensus genomes generated were used for analysis using Cluster Investigation and Virus Epidemiological Tool software. Patient timelines were obtained using electronic hospital records.
Findings
In total, 787 patients discharged from hospitals to care homes were identified. Of these, 776 (99%) were ruled out for subsequent introduction of SARS-CoV-2 into care homes. However, for 10 episodes, the results were inconclusive as there was low genomic diversity in consensus genomes or no sequencing data were available. Only one discharge episode had a genomic, time and location link to positive cases during hospital admission, leading to 10 positive cases in their care home.
Conclusion
The majority of patients discharged from hospitals were ruled out for introduction of SARS-CoV-2 into care homes, highlighting the importance of screening all new admissions when faced with a novel emerging virus and no available vaccine.
Introduction
Care homes experienced high case numbers of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) during the pandemic, and this led to high mortality from coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) [
[1]- Comas-Herrera A.
- Zalakaín J.
- Lemmon E.
- Henderson D.
- Litwin C.
- Hsu A.T.
- et al.
Mortality associated with COVID-19 in care homes: international evidence.
]. Care homes have a unique population consisting of multi-disciplinary staff and many elderly residents who are particularly susceptible to severe COVID-19 [
[2]- Graham N.S.N.
- Junghans C.
- Downes R.
- Sendal C.
- Lai H.
- McKirdy A.
- et al.
SARS-CoV-2 infection, clinical features and outcome of COVID-19 in United Kingdom nursing homes.
]. SARS-CoV-2 infections can spread more quickly within care homes than in the surrounding community due to the number of residents, their proximity and the level of nursing care required [
[3]- Arons M.M.
- Hatfield K.M.
- Reddy S.C.
- Kimball A.
- James A.
- Jacobs J.R.
- et al.
Presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections and transmission in a skilled nursing facility.
]. Around half of the deaths reported in Scotland from COVID-19 have occurred in care home populations, resulting in life expectancy in these settings falling by 6 months [
[4]- Burton J.K.
- Reid M.
- Gribben C.
- Caldwell D.
- Clark D.N.
- Hanlon P.
- et al.
Impact of COVID-19 on care-home mortality and life expectancy in Scotland.
]. One healthcare region, Lothian, reported that over one-third of care homes had an outbreak during the first epidemic wave [
[5]- Burton J.K.
- Bayne G.
- Evans C.
- Garbe F.
- Gorman D.
- Honhold N.
- et al.
Evolution and effects of COVID-19 outbreaks in care homes: a population analysis in 189 care homes in one geographical region of the UK.
]. These residents were identified as particularly susceptible to further epidemic waves without the protection of a vaccine or effective treatment [
[5]- Burton J.K.
- Bayne G.
- Evans C.
- Garbe F.
- Gorman D.
- Honhold N.
- et al.
Evolution and effects of COVID-19 outbreaks in care homes: a population analysis in 189 care homes in one geographical region of the UK.
].
Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) is a powerful tool that can add another layer to epidemiological information, providing insights into outbreak transmission dynamics and relatedness between cases. Clusters of resident and staff cases which have identical or very similar genomes have shown onward transmission within care homes [
[2]- Graham N.S.N.
- Junghans C.
- Downes R.
- Sendal C.
- Lai H.
- McKirdy A.
- et al.
SARS-CoV-2 infection, clinical features and outcome of COVID-19 in United Kingdom nursing homes.
,
6- Ladhani S.N.
- Chow J.Y.
- Janarthanan R.
- Fok J.
- Crawley-Boevey E.
- Vusirikala A.
- et al.
Investigation of SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks in six care homes in London.
,
7- Hamilton W.L.
- Tonkin-Hill G.
- Smith E.R.
- Aggarwal D.
- Houldcroft C.J.
- Warne B.
- et al.
Genomic epidemiology of COVID-19 in care homes in the east of England.
,
8- Van den Besselaar J.H.
- Sikkema R.S.
- Koene F.M.
- Van Buul L.W.
- Oude Munnink B.B.
- Frénay I.
- et al.
Are presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections in nursing home residents unrecognized symptomatic infections? Sequence and metadata from weekly testing in an extensive nursing home outbreak.
]. The number of introductions into a care home can be established, and both single dominant clusters and multiple clusters were observed during the first epidemic wave [
[7]- Hamilton W.L.
- Tonkin-Hill G.
- Smith E.R.
- Aggarwal D.
- Houldcroft C.J.
- Warne B.
- et al.
Genomic epidemiology of COVID-19 in care homes in the east of England.
,
9- Lemieux J.E.
- Siddle K.J.
- Shaw B.M.
- Loreth C.
- Schaffner S.F.
- Gladden-Young A.
- et al.
Phylogenetic analysis of SARS-CoV-2 in Boston highlights the impact of superspreading events.
,
10- Page A.J.
- Mather A.E.
- Le-Viet T.
- Meader E.J.
- Alikhan N.F.
- Kay G.L.
- et al.
Large-scale sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 genomes from one region allows detailed epidemiology and enables local outbreak management.
,
11- Taylor J.
- Carter R.J.
- Lehnertz N.
- Kazazian L.
- Sullivan M.
- Xiong W.
- et al.
Serial testing for SARS-CoV-2 and virus whole genome sequencing inform infection risk at two skilled nursing facilities with COVID-19 outbreaks — Minnesota, April–June 2020.
].
The source of SARS-CoV-2 introductions into care homes has not been well studied to date. Potential sources include residents returning from hospitals, new residents from the community or other care homes, visitors and staff. It has been suggested that staff working across different sites could potentially be sources of introduction [
[12]- Bigelow B.F.
- Tang O.
- Toc G.R.
- Stracker N.
- Sheikh F.
- Jacobs Slifka K.M.
- et al.
Transmission of SARS-CoV-2 involving residents receiving dialysis in a nursing home – Maryland, April 2020.
,
[13]- McMichael T.M.
- Currie D.W.
- Clark S.
- Pogosjans S.
- Kay M.
- Schwartz N.G.
- et al.
Epidemiology of COVID-19 in a long-term care facility in King County, Washington.
]. Discharged patients have also been suggested, but these studies require further investigation to answer the question [
[7]- Hamilton W.L.
- Tonkin-Hill G.
- Smith E.R.
- Aggarwal D.
- Houldcroft C.J.
- Warne B.
- et al.
Genomic epidemiology of COVID-19 in care homes in the east of England.
,
[10]- Page A.J.
- Mather A.E.
- Le-Viet T.
- Meader E.J.
- Alikhan N.F.
- Kay G.L.
- et al.
Large-scale sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 genomes from one region allows detailed epidemiology and enables local outbreak management.
]. A few specific care home outbreaks have investigated sources of introduction; however, larger studies to investigate sources for care home outbreaks are lacking [
[8]- Van den Besselaar J.H.
- Sikkema R.S.
- Koene F.M.
- Van Buul L.W.
- Oude Munnink B.B.
- Frénay I.
- et al.
Are presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections in nursing home residents unrecognized symptomatic infections? Sequence and metadata from weekly testing in an extensive nursing home outbreak.
,
[14]- Voeten H.A.C.M.
- Sikkema R.S.
- Damen M.
- Oude Munnink B.B.
- Arends C.
- Stobberingh E.
- et al.
Unraveling the modes of transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) during a nursing home outbreak: looking beyond the church superspreading event.
].
During the first epidemic wave, many hospital patients were discharged back into care homes with limited testing available, particularly in the initial stage of the pandemic [
[15]Let’s be open and honest about COVID-19 deaths in care homes.
]. Initially, symptomatic cases alone were tested, before testing capacity increased to screen all residents and staff in care homes. A significant number of COVID-19 deaths in care homes were recorded, and this has raised interest regarding patients discharged from hospitals to care homes during that time. It is possible that SARS-CoV-2 could have been introduced into care homes following hospital discharge. This study of one healthcare region in Scotland aimed to assess whether, in the first epidemic wave, SARS-CoV-2 may have been introduced into care homes following the discharge of hospital patients using WGS data and detailed epidemiological information.
Discussion
For the first epidemic wave, the question regarding the introduction of SARS-CoV-2 into care homes by patients discharged from hospital has long remained unanswered. This study has shown that hospital introduction could not be ruled out following discharge to care homes for 11 of 787 discharge episodes. In 10 discharge episodes, the result was inconclusive based on limited sequencing information or low genetic diversity of SARS-CoV-2. For one discharge episode, a genomic, time and location link to hospital inpatients was identified. Most outbreaks were therefore likely to be introduced by other sources.
CIVET was used to investigate care home outbreaks and sources of introductions; this tool has been used to study cluster analysis for outbreaks previously [
[20]- O’Toole Á Hill V.
- Jackson B.
- Dewar R.
- Sahadeo N.
- Colquhoun R.
- et al.
Genomics-informed outbreak investigations of SARS-CoV-2 using civet.
,
[21]- Francis R.
- Billam H.
- Clarke M.
- Yates C.
- Tsoleridis T.
- Berry L.
- et al.
The impact of real-time whole-genome sequencing in controlling healthcare-associated SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks.
]. CIVET enabled the comparison of sequences within the care home and with background data to identify possible community or hospital genetically related cases. The mutation rate of SARS-CoV-2 was estimated to be approximately two mutations per month on average during the pandemic period [
[22]- Peñarrubia L.
- Ruiz M.
- Porco R.
- Rao S.N.
- Juanola-Falgarona M.
- Manissero D.
- et al.
Multiple assays in a real-time RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 panel can mitigate the risk of loss of sensitivity by new genomic variants during the COVID-19 outbreak.
]. Therefore, in this study, cases within 14 days were classified as potentially linked if the consensus genomes differed by at least one SNP, in agreement with other studies [
[14]- Voeten H.A.C.M.
- Sikkema R.S.
- Damen M.
- Oude Munnink B.B.
- Arends C.
- Stobberingh E.
- et al.
Unraveling the modes of transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) during a nursing home outbreak: looking beyond the church superspreading event.
,
23- Jeffery-Smith A.
- Dun-Campbell K.
- Janarthanan R.
- Fok J.
- Crawley-Boevey E.
- Vusirikala A.
- et al.
Infection and transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in London care homes reporting no cases or outbreaks of COVID-19: prospective observational cohort study, England 2020.
,
24- Paltansing S.
- Sikkema R.S.
- de Man S.J.
- Koopmans M.P.G.
Oude Munnink BB, de Man P. Transmission of SARS-CoV-2 among healthcare workers and patients in a teaching hospital in the Netherlands confirmed by whole-genome sequencing.
,
25- Turcinovic J.
- Schaeffer B.
- Taylor B.
- Bouton T.
- Odom-Mabey A.
- Weber S.
- et al.
Understanding early pandemic SARS-CoV-2 transmission in a medical center by incorporating public sequencing databases to mitigate bias.
]. The study findings agree with others suggesting that there were single and multiple clusters in the first epidemic wave [
[9]- Lemieux J.E.
- Siddle K.J.
- Shaw B.M.
- Loreth C.
- Schaffner S.F.
- Gladden-Young A.
- et al.
Phylogenetic analysis of SARS-CoV-2 in Boston highlights the impact of superspreading events.
,
[14]- Voeten H.A.C.M.
- Sikkema R.S.
- Damen M.
- Oude Munnink B.B.
- Arends C.
- Stobberingh E.
- et al.
Unraveling the modes of transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) during a nursing home outbreak: looking beyond the church superspreading event.
].
It was possible to rule out most hospital discharges as potential sources of introduction of SARS-CoV-2 into care homes based on the clinical review and the infectious period lasting <14 days [
,
[26]- Lauer S.
- Grantz K.
- Bi Q.
- Jones F.
- Zheng Q.
- Meredith H.
- et al.
The incubation period of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) from publicly reported confirmed cases: estimation and application.
]. If SARS-CoV-2 was introduced into a care home at hospital discharge, one would expect to see positive cases in the care home within 14 days. As found in the present study, Hamilton
et al. showed that most patients discharged from hospital were not infectious at the time of discharge [
[7]- Hamilton W.L.
- Tonkin-Hill G.
- Smith E.R.
- Aggarwal D.
- Houldcroft C.J.
- Warne B.
- et al.
Genomic epidemiology of COVID-19 in care homes in the east of England.
].
The addition of WGS analysis enabled hospital discharge episodes to be ruled out as sources of SARS-CoV-2 introduction into care homes as these episodes had a consensus genome that clustered with sequences from an outbreak already in the care home or community cases. Most episodes were positive prior to or within 2 days of hospital admission, so the discharged patient likely acquired the virus from the outbreak in the care home before hospital admission. However, they could still have been infectious when discharged to the care home. These episodes were ruled out on the basis that SARS-CoV-2 had already been introduced into the care home. The prevalence in the community was likely very high during the first epidemic wave, as no vaccines were available at the time. A large study by Emerson
et al. showed that care home outbreaks were not associated with hospital discharge, and this agrees with the present finding of likely introduction from other sources [
[27]- Emmerson C.
- Adamson J.P.
- Turner D.
- Gravenor M.B.
- Salmon J.
- Cottrell S.
- et al.
Risk factors for outbreaks of COVID-19 in care homes following hospital discharge: a national cohort analysis.
]. The sequencing data from most care homes show clusters of care home cases with background community cases rather than hospital cases, indicating that community introduction was far more likely. Other studies have shown that most infections in care homes are community acquired [
[7]- Hamilton W.L.
- Tonkin-Hill G.
- Smith E.R.
- Aggarwal D.
- Houldcroft C.J.
- Warne B.
- et al.
Genomic epidemiology of COVID-19 in care homes in the east of England.
,
[10]- Page A.J.
- Mather A.E.
- Le-Viet T.
- Meader E.J.
- Alikhan N.F.
- Kay G.L.
- et al.
Large-scale sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 genomes from one region allows detailed epidemiology and enables local outbreak management.
].
For one discharge episode, CIVET revealed two hospital inpatient sequences within the same cluster as CH1 sequences. Further review of patient timelines showed that the discharged patient was located on the same ward as two inpatients with a consensus genome of high similarity. It is known that direct contact between individuals is a key factor in transmission [
[28]- Ellingford J.M.
- George R.
- McDermott J.H.
- Ahmad S.
- Edgerley J.J.
- Gokhale D.
- et al.
Genomic and healthcare dynamics of nosocomial SARS-CoV-2 transmission.
]. As there was evidence of the discharged patient being the link between cases in the hospital and cases in the care home, hospital introduction could not be ruled out. Van Den Besselaar
et al. also suggested the introduction of SARS-CoV-2 into a care home by a patient discharged from hospital using WGS data, where clustering was found between cases in residents and a hospital outbreak [
[8]- Van den Besselaar J.H.
- Sikkema R.S.
- Koene F.M.
- Van Buul L.W.
- Oude Munnink B.B.
- Frénay I.
- et al.
Are presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections in nursing home residents unrecognized symptomatic infections? Sequence and metadata from weekly testing in an extensive nursing home outbreak.
]
.For 10 discharge episodes, it was not possible to assess whether SARS-CoV-2 was introduced to a care home by a patient discharged from hospital as the results were inconclusive. Low genetic diversity among positive cases during the first epidemic wave is well known because SARS-CoV-2 has only emerged recently in the human population [
[29]- van Dorp L.
- Acman M.
- Richard D.
- Shaw L.P.
- Ford C.E.
- Ormond L.
- et al.
Emergence of genomic diversity and recurrent mutations in SARS-CoV-2.
,
[30]- Villabona-Arenas C.
- Hanage W.
- Tully D.
Phylogenetic interpretation during outbreaks requires caution.
]. Therefore, WGS could not add any further information to these investigations, as the introduction could have come from any source. Five discharge episodes were not the first positive case identified in the care home. However, it was possible there could have been multiple introductions, so these episodes could not be ruled out for discharge introduction.
A limitation of this study is that some patients discharged from hospital were not tested for COVID-19 due to limited availability of testing at the early stages of the pandemic. However, those that were symptomatic or had clinical suspicion of COVID were tested. It is possible that asymptomatic-positive patients discharged from hospital could have introduced SARS-CoV-2 to care homes, as suggested by Jeffery-Smith
et al. [
[23]- Jeffery-Smith A.
- Dun-Campbell K.
- Janarthanan R.
- Fok J.
- Crawley-Boevey E.
- Vusirikala A.
- et al.
Infection and transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in London care homes reporting no cases or outbreaks of COVID-19: prospective observational cohort study, England 2020.
]. The present study relates to a period before vaccines were introduced, and when asymptomatic infection was less likely in older generations compared with younger generations [
[31]- Syangtan G.
- Bista S.
- Dawadi P.
- Rayamajhee B.
- Shrestha L.
- Tuladhar R.
- et al.
Asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 carriers: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
]. There has been evidence of asymptomatic infections in care home residents, and this led to the recommendation for regular screening [
[3]- Arons M.M.
- Hatfield K.M.
- Reddy S.C.
- Kimball A.
- James A.
- Jacobs J.R.
- et al.
Presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections and transmission in a skilled nursing facility.
,
[6]- Ladhani S.N.
- Chow J.Y.
- Janarthanan R.
- Fok J.
- Crawley-Boevey E.
- Vusirikala A.
- et al.
Investigation of SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks in six care homes in London.
,
[32]- Kennelly S.
- Dyer A.
- Noonan C.
- Martin R.
- Kennelly S.
- Martin A.
- et al.
Asymptomatic carriage rates and case fatality of SARS-CoV-2 infection in residents and staff in Irish nursing homes.
,
[33]- Kimball A.
- Hatfield K.
- Arons M.
- James A.
- Taylor J.
- Spicer K.
- et al.
Asymptomatic and presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections in residents of a long-term care skilled nursing facility – King County, Washington, March 2020.
]. However, in these outbreaks, there are nearly always symptomatic cases, which suggests that if SARS-CoV-2 is introduced into this population, there will be a symptomatic case. Additionally, cases which were initially thought to be asymptomatic were, in fact, pre-symptomatic, as they developed symptoms after testing [
[3]- Arons M.M.
- Hatfield K.M.
- Reddy S.C.
- Kimball A.
- James A.
- Jacobs J.R.
- et al.
Presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections and transmission in a skilled nursing facility.
,
[33]- Kimball A.
- Hatfield K.
- Arons M.
- James A.
- Taylor J.
- Spicer K.
- et al.
Asymptomatic and presymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections in residents of a long-term care skilled nursing facility – King County, Washington, March 2020.
]. Many of the episodes that were not tested at hospital discharge in the present study were discharged to care homes with no reported cases [
[5]- Burton J.K.
- Bayne G.
- Evans C.
- Garbe F.
- Gorman D.
- Honhold N.
- et al.
Evolution and effects of COVID-19 outbreaks in care homes: a population analysis in 189 care homes in one geographical region of the UK.
].
Identifying all positive care home residents is a challenge as data systems can have poor data quality, and it remains unlikely that all hospital discharges to care homes in the period have been captured. Another limitation is the number of cases unable to be sequenced due to low RNA input for sequencing or because residents were missed. The analysis is incomplete for some outbreaks, and it is possible that multiple introductions may not have been identified. However, not every case is needed to rule out the introduction of SARS-CoV-2 into care homes from patients discharged from hospital, as shown in the present study.
This study highlights the importance of utilizing a combined approach of epidemiology and WGS to tackle investigations of sources for SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks. WGS can add another layer to investigations by revealing similarities and differences between consensus genomes. This information can link or rule out cases which would otherwise remain concealed. Understanding how SARS-CoV-2 was introduced can help to prevent further outbreaks in a very vulnerable population, and identify areas to improve infection control.
In conclusion, this study found that most outbreaks in care homes in the first wave were not sourced by patients discharged from hospital. Infection control strategies should focus on all admissions and sources into the care home when faced with a novel emerging virus without a vaccine. This study has shown that, for future outbreaks, it is possible to combine clinical and sequencing information to investigate the source of virus introduction.
Article info
Publication history
Published online: March 09, 2023
Accepted:
February 12,
2023
Received:
December 9,
2022
Copyright
© 2023 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of The Healthcare Infection Society.